Supreme Court denies Appeal on dischargeability issue of student loan debt

Last Monday, the Supreme Court decided it wouldn't consider an appeal from our very own Seventh Circuit by a man from Wisconsin who owes $260,000 in student loans from business and law school and was seeking to have the loans discharged in bankruptcy. 

The current test in place that determines whether student loans are dischargeable in bankruptcy is called the Brunner Test.  It basically says that student loans are not dischargeable in bankruptcy unless you can show an undue hardship.  Sounds easy right? Wrong.

Showing that your student loans present an undue hardship is nearly impossible in practice. 

This Brunner test adopted a standard for "undue hardship" requiring a three-part showing: (1) that the debtor cannot maintain, based on current income and expenses, a "minimal" standard of living for herself and her dependents if forced to repay the loans; (2) that additional circumstances exist indicating that this state of affairs is likely to persist for a significant portion of the repayment period of the student loans; and (3) that the debtor has made good faith efforts to repay the loans.   In re Brunner, 46 B.R.752, 756 (S.D.N.Y. 1985).

Mark Tetzlaff, who filed a Chapter 7 Bankruptcy in 2012, was asking the court to use a less strict standard to determine the dischargeability of his student loans.  This test, known as "The Totality of Circumstances Test" and is arguably an easier test than the Brunner test.  

Either way, the Supreme Court refused to hear his appeal, leaving the issue partially unresolved.   For Mr. Tetzlaff, many will argue that he can still enter into a low Income Based Repayment (your IBR payment could be zero in some cases), leaving him with the ability to discharge his student loan debt over time, anyway.

Read more about it here. 

Pay Debts With Blood or Go to Jail: The New Reality If You Don't Have Cash

Here is a great article about the reality of not paying debts and court fines for many people.

“What we’re seeing is that in cities big and small, urban and rural people are being jailed, because they can’t afford to pay fines. [And] what appears to be fueling the rise of debtors' prisons is the tightening of municipal budgets and the desire to look towards fines and fees as a source of municipal revenue.”

Many of my clients have several thousands of dollars of unpaid tickets and fines. Once you have your driver's license suspended it is very difficult to reinstate your license through the State.

Chapter 13 Bankruptcy offers a more affordable repayment plan for your debt, and you can avoid jail time for driving with a suspended license.

http://www.thestreet.com/story/13336058/1/pay-debts-with-blood-or-go-to-jail-the-new-reality-if-you-don-t-have-cash.html

50 cent files for bankruptcy! Wait, what does that mean anyway?

Tip: don't show up to your 341 meeting wearing all your gold chains.

As you all have heard by now, Curtis James Jackson III (aka 50 cent) has filed for bankruptcy protection.  Many of the articles I've read online make it seem like he's broke and living on the streets.  But 50 cent filed for Chapter 11 Bankruptcy, a type of bankruptcy most regular people don't know much about.  Very long story short, he can keep assets and continue making money, he just has to pay back creditors according to a bankruptcy plan and most importantly, creditors have to wait!  This article from complex.com sort of explains it: "50 Cent Filing for Bankruptcy Does Not Mean He's Broke".

For most regular folks your bankruptcy options are usually a Chapter 7 or Chapter 13.  Either you have no assets and low income and you get rid of your unsecured debt in a Chapter 7, or you might have some assets and a big higher income and you repay some of your debt in a Chapter 13.  Read more about your choices here.

And just for fun here is a list of famous people who have filed for bankruptcy:

• Abe Lincoln
• Thomas Jefferson
• Walt Disney
• Henry Ford
• Larry King
• Donald Trump
• Mark Twain
• Burt Reynolds
• M.C. Hammer
• Cindy Lauper
• Mike Tyson
• Toni Braxton

and many more.

For many people bankruptcy is a necessary step to reorganize their lives after a financial set back.

US Department of Education issues advisory letter on student loans and bankruptcy!

If you know anything about bankruptcy and student loans, you know that they do not work well together.  Student loans are not dischargeable in either a Chapter 7 or Chapter 13 Bankruptcy unless you file an adversary proceeding and can show that the loans present an undue hardship on the Debtor.  The test called the "Brunner Test" is very difficult to pass unless a Debtor has a severe illness and no prospect of ever repaying the debts again.

The US Department of Education issued a letter today providing guidance to lenders when dealing with student loan discharge claims.  The letter reiterates how only a Debtor in an extreme situation should be issued a discharge of their student loans in bankruptcy.  Although the letter does direct student loan lenders to follow a two-step analysis to determine whether they should object to an attempt at discharging student loans in a bankruptcy case, the result is essentially the same: Student loans are extremely difficult to discharge in bankruptcy.

The two-step analysis suggested by the US Department of Education is as follows:

1. First a loan holder must evaluate a borrower's undue hardship claim and determine whether the holder believes the repayment would constitute an undue hardship according to the legal standard set by the Federal Courts.  (Essentially the Brunner test).  If the loan holder determines that there would be an undue hardship, they can consent and not oppose the discharge.  (Although they could still object at this point).

If the loan holder believes there is no undue hardship they then move on to step 2.

2. The loan holder should then weigh the cost of objecting to the undue hardship claim in court, with consenting to the discharge.

Long story short, this letter provides an analysis of student loan debt dischargeability and provides some guidance to lenders on how to approach adversary proceedings, but the takeaway is the same: Student loans are VERY difficult to discharge in bankruptcy.

It is also important to note that an adversary proceeding is often times a lengthy and expensive proceeding, and many Debtor can not afford to hire their bankruptcy attorney to litigate these matters.

The entire letter issued by the US Department of Education can be found here.